4 Face Cleansers Tested: Which One Actually Worked

4 Face Cleansers Tested: Which One Actually Worked

Thank you for reading this post, don’t forget to subscribe!

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Your price is not affected. Affiliate Disclosure

광고

Advertisement

Around mid-March, I started noticing tiny bumps appearing around my jawline. At first I thought they’d disappear on their own, but by day seven they’d actually gotten worse. Before scheduling a dermatologist appointment, I figured I’d try switching my cleanser—which I’d been using the same one since college. Five years with one product. I know, I know.

My skin had completely changed once I hit my late twenties. My T-zone would get shiny but my cheeks felt tight. Makeup wasn’t sitting the way it used to. But the real problem? Within five minutes of cleansing, my face would feel so pulled and uncomfortable that I’d be counting down the seconds until I could apply toner.

So I decided to test four different cleansers over a week, alternating morning and night. I figured it was worth trying before dealing with dermatology appointment wait times and copays. Bottom line: two of them actually made a difference, one made things worse, and one was just okay.

La Roche-Posay Toleriane — The Dermatologist’s Darling

This one keeps popping up in skincare forums. I grabbed a sample from the pharmacy and tested it for three days. The lather felt incredibly soft, and there was barely any tightness after rinsing. It runs around $20 for 5 oz.

What I noticed: it doesn’t clean super thoroughly. It’s great for a morning rinse if you didn’t wear makeup, but in the evening after sunscreen? It felt a bit wimpy. So I started using a cleansing oil first, then this as a second cleanse. By day three, those jawline bumps seemed to be calming down.

The downside is the price-to-volume ratio. Five ounces lasts maybe six weeks if you’re using it twice daily. That’s over $10 a month just on cleanser, which felt steep to me.

CeraVe Foaming Cleanser — Best Bang for Your Buck

I picked this up right next to the La Roche-Posay at the pharmacy. For around $10 for a 12 oz bottle, the value was honestly ridiculous. It comes in a pump bottle, which is super convenient.

The lather isn’t as luxurious as the La Roche-Posay, but it cleans just as well. No tightness afterward either. Here’s the real win: a 12 oz bottle will last three months. That’s less than $5 a month. You can’t beat that.

One quirk: the pump dispenses a lot. I made the rookie mistake of using two full pumps the first time and had foam everywhere. About one and a half pumps is the sweet spot. Also, the clear plastic bottle looks a little plain sitting on your shower shelf, but that’s such a minor complaint.

Innisfree Super Volcanic Pore Clay Mask — Nice Smell, Meh Results

I’d bought this on sale months ago and decided to give it a shot. I alternated it with the CeraVe for a couple of days. The green tea scent was lovely during my morning cleanse. It’s also budget-friendly at around $10 for 5.3 oz.

But here’s what happened: about five minutes after rinsing, my cheeks started feeling dry and pulled. My T-zone was fine, but my cheeks and mouth area got tight. I have combination skin leaning toward drier, so this might actually work for someone with truly oily skin, but it definitely wasn’t my match.

If you’re sensitive to fragrance, skip this too. The scent is nice, but those jawline bumps actually got worse during the two days I used it. Everyone’s skin is different, but I stopped testing this one after that.

광고

Cosrx Low pH Good Morning Gel Cleanser — For Oil-Control Seekers

This was constantly ranked #1 on beauty shopping sites, so I had to try it. Around $10 for 5 oz, and it’s formulated at pH 5.0–6.0, which is supposed to be gentle and balanced.

It’s a gel formula rather than foamy, so don’t expect a thick lather. The cleansing power is definitely there though. With the tea tree oil in it, your skin feels really squeaky-clean and slightly tight. If you love that stripped, refreshed feeling, you’d probably adore this. For oily skin, I bet it’s amazing.

For me, though? My cheeks and jawline felt uncomfortably tight within ten minutes. I’d basically need to apply toner immediately or I’d feel uncomfortable. I used it for about three days and the jawline bumps didn’t improve—plus I noticed a little redness starting on my cheeks, so I stopped.

If you have oily skin and pores are your main concern, this could be perfect. But if you’re combination or dry, probably best to pass.

Product Price Range Cleansing Power Best For
La Roche-Posay Toleriane Around $20 Medium Sensitive skin, fragrance-free preference
CeraVe Foaming Around $10 Medium Budget-conscious, large bottle preference
Innisfree Green Tea Around $10 Light Oily skin, loves a good scent
Cosrx Low pH Around $10 Strong Oily skin, pore concerns

Advertisement

One Week Later: Did My Skin Actually Improve?

So after a week of alternating between CeraVe and La Roche-Posay, those jawline bumps had calmed down by about 80%. Nothing new was popping up either. I was genuinely surprised—I thought I’d definitely need to see a dermatologist.

I ended up going with CeraVe as my everyday pick. La Roche-Posay worked really well, but I couldn’t justify spending over $10 a month on cleanser. CeraVe’s 12 oz bottle will last three months, so I’m spending less than $5 monthly. The results are basically identical, so why pay more?

I’m still using it now, and those jawline bumps are completely gone. My cheeks don’t feel tight anymore either, and I’m honestly shocked at how much switching cleansers actually mattered.

“If you notice your skin changing in your late twenties, start with switching your cleanser before you book that dermatologist appointment.”

In hindsight, using the same cleanser for five years was definitely the problem. Your skin is just different at 20 versus 27. These days there’s no tightness after washing, makeup actually stays put, and I don’t have to rush to apply toner the second I’m done cleansing.

See CeraVe Foaming Cleanser Prices

How to Pick Based on Your Skin Type

From what I’ve tested, if you have oily skin, go for either Cosrx or Innisfree. You’ll love that squeaky-clean feeling, and the cleansing power is genuinely strong.

If your skin leans dry or sensitive, I’d recommend either La Roche-Posay or CeraVe. Neither one leaves that uncomfortable tight feeling, and La Roche-Posay specifically has zero fragrance. If you have combination skin like me, alternating CeraVe in the morning and La Roche-Posay at night actually worked really well.

On a budget? CeraVe is the no-brainer. You’re paying less per month than any of the others, and the results stack up against products that cost twice as much. That’s what I’m sticking with.

Questions I Keep Getting

Q. Does switching cleansers really get rid of jawline bumps?

In my case, they cleared up about 80% in a week. But—and this is important—if the bumps are from hormones or stress, a new cleanser won’t fix that. Give it two weeks. If nothing’s changed, definitely see a dermatologist.

Q. Which is better: CeraVe or La Roche-Posay?

They perform similarly, but CeraVe wins on value. You’re looking at $20 for 5 oz of La Roche-Posay versus $10 for 12 oz of CeraVe. If budget’s not a concern, La Roche-Posay feels slightly more luxe. But honestly? CeraVe gives you the same clean feeling for a third of the price.

광고


DCT Family Guide

DCT Family Guide · Laurent’s Mom · Last updated 2026-05-03

Hands-on reviews from a Korean mother of two.

About the author →  ·  Disclosure →

Personal experience-based. Product, policy, and price details may change over time — verify with the source before purchase.

💬 Frequently Asked Questions

❓ How long should I test a new cleanser before deciding if it works?

Give it at least 3-5 days to see how your skin reacts, paying attention to tightness, dryness, or changes in bumps or texture. If you notice immediate irritation or worsening breakouts within the first couple uses, that’s a sign to stop right away.

❓ Can I use different cleansers for morning and night?

Absolutely—many people use a gentler cleanser in the morning and a stronger one at night to remove sunscreen and makeup. Just make sure both are appropriate for your skin type so you’re not over-stripping or under-cleansing.

❓ What does it mean if my face feels tight after washing?

That tight, pulled feeling usually means your cleanser is stripping too much of your skin’s natural oils. It’s a sign the formula is too harsh for your skin type, and you should switch to something gentler or more hydrating.

❓ Is double cleansing necessary if I’m not wearing makeup?

If you’re only wearing sunscreen or have oily skin, a single cleanse with a good foaming or gel cleanser is usually enough. Double cleansing is most helpful when you need to remove heavy makeup, waterproof products, or very stubborn sunscreen that one wash doesn’t fully clear.


DCT Family Guide에서 더 알아보기

구독을 신청하면 최신 게시물을 이메일로 받아볼 수 있습니다.

DCT Family Guide에서 더 알아보기

지금 구독하여 계속 읽고 전체 아카이브에 액세스하세요.

계속 읽기